Attorneys general challenge CFTC sports contracts rule

A bipartisan coalition of 43 state attorneys general and the District of Columbia has asked federal regulators to withdraw the proposed CFTC sports contracts rule. The coalition filed its comment on November 18, opposing an effort to define sports event contracts as swaps under federal commodities law. The attorneys general argue that the proposed definition would interfere with states’ authority to license, restrict, or prohibit sports betting.
The filing responds to a Commodity Futures Trading Commission proposal published on October 19. The agency seeks to expressly include event contracts in the definition of a swap, covering contracts tied to sports, politics, culture, and weather. The attorneys general focused their objections on sports contracts and the possibility that a federal classification could be used to challenge state gambling requirements. The proposal was published with a November 18 deadline for public comments.
Ohio Attorney General Andy Wilson co-led the coalition alongside his counterparts in Kentucky, Maryland, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, Tennessee, and Utah. Thirty-five other states and D.C. joined them. The group submitted its objections through the federal rulemaking process and requested an explicit clarification that sports-betting contracts fall outside the commission’s swaps jurisdiction. Their intervention addresses the regulatory treatment of sports-related prediction markets rather than the agency’s broader proposal covering other event categories.
Proposed CFTC sports contracts rule draws legal objections
The coalition argues that the Commodity Exchange Act does not authorize the CFTC to extend the swap definition to cover sports bets. Its letter also challenges the proposal on procedural and administrative-law grounds and raises constitutional objections to the agency’s interpretation. Federal appellate courts have reached differing conclusions about the classification of sports event contracts. The CFTC cited those conflicting decisions in its proposal, including rulings from the Third, Sixth, and Ninth Circuits, as part of its explanation for seeking regulatory clarification.
The officials separately questioned whether the commission could adopt the rule with only one commissioner serving. Their letter argues that the agency lacks the necessary quorum. The statutory authority question and the quorum objection concern different aspects of the rulemaking process. One challenges the scope of the CFTC’s regulatory powers, while the other concerns the commission’s ability to finalize the proposal. The coalition is seeking withdrawal of the CFTC sports contracts rule on the grounds presented in its filing.
In announcing the filing, Wilson said, “A sports bet isn’t a derivative just because the CFTC says so.” His office also warned that the proposed classification could give established sportsbooks a reason to reorganize their products as prediction markets. The coalition argues that this would weaken state oversight of licensing, age restrictions, and safeguards for people at risk of gambling harm. These concerns form part of the states’ opposition to treating sports-related event contracts as federally regulated derivatives.
Senate hearing addresses CFTC sports contracts jurisdiction
The filing followed a November 17 Senate Agriculture Committee hearing for CFTC nominees Nathan Anonick and Matthew Rowland. Senators questioned both nominees about the boundary between sports event contracts and sports betting. The nominees discussed the complexity of the issue and the role of litigation without committing to the coalition’s position during the hearing. The committee’s official record identifies both nominees as candidates for commissioner positions at the CFTC.
The November filing follows another bipartisan intervention in July, when attorneys general urged the commission to recognize states’ authority over sports-related prediction markets. The latest letter responds to a specific regulatory text and seeks withdrawal of the proposal alongside an explicit clarification about the status of sports-betting contracts. The November 18 submission places the states’ objections within the formal rulemaking record. The CFTC has not adopted the proposed definition, leaving the regulatory treatment of these contracts subject to the existing legal framework and ongoing disputes.



