Evolution settlement leaves Black Cube in case

The Evolution settlement with Calcagni & Kanefsky LLP removes the New Jersey law firm from a defamation case over a report that alleged the live casino supplier’s games were accessible in prohibited markets. Lawyers for the firm disclosed the agreement on November 17 at a hearing in New Jersey Superior Court. The terms are confidential, and Black Cube remains the sole defendant in the current proceedings.
The settlement concerns the law firm’s role in circulating the 2021 report. Calcagni & Kanefsky sent it to gaming regulators in New Jersey and Pennsylvania. The report alleged that Evolution games were accessible in jurisdictions subject to U.S. sanctions, including Iran, and in other prohibited markets. Evolution disputed the allegations. The lawsuit eventually brought to light the identities of the firm that produced the report and the company that commissioned it.
Black Cube’s lawyers asked to see the settlement, arguing that the agreement could be relevant to the remaining litigation. Evolution’s counsel declined to disclose it, citing confidentiality. Judge John Porto indicated that compelling disclosure could require a court order. The hearing did not publicly establish the financial terms of the agreement.
Black Cube challenges Evolution’s defamation claim
Black Cube is seeking dismissal under New Jersey’s Uniform Public Expression Protection Act. The law provides a procedure for challenging certain claims arising from public expression. Black Cube argues that its investigation rested on genuine evidence and that reporting suspected regulatory violations is protected activity. Evolution disputes the reliability of the material and maintains that the report was intended to damage its business and competitive position.
Playtech acknowledged commissioning the investigation after its involvement became public in 2025. The company denied wrongdoing and maintained that the work raised legitimate questions about Evolution’s business practices. Evolution asked the court in April 2026 for permission to add Playtech and other parties. Porto denied the request without prejudice in June, putting Black Cube’s challenge first. Playtech’s role in commissioning the investigation is therefore part of the dispute’s history, while the pending defamation proceedings concern Black Cube.
New Jersey closed its regulatory investigation in 2024
The New Jersey Division of Gaming Enforcement took up the allegations after receiving the report in November 2021. Evolution said in a February 2024 market disclosure that the regulator had closed the investigation without further action. According to the company, the division found no evidence that Evolution had authorized, allowed or materially benefited from operators offering its games in markets the regulator considers prohibited.
Evolution also said it conducted an internal review and enhanced its processes. The company said those changes did not relate to any jurisdictional violation. The regulatory investigation dealt with the allegations about access to Evolution’s games. The New Jersey court proceedings now concern the report’s production and distribution and whether Evolution’s defamation claim against Black Cube can proceed.



