Regulation & Legal
Trending

EU court leaves Malta’s Bill 55 unresolved

The Court of Justice of the European Union declined to decide whether Malta’s Bill 55 is compatible with EU law, ruling on November 19 that an Austrian court’s request for a preliminary ruling was inadmissible. The judges found that answering the questions about Malta’s gambling legislation was unnecessary to resolve the case before the Commercial Court in Vienna. The judgment leaves the underlying question of EU law open.

The case, Spielerschutz Sigma, grew out of efforts to recover online gambling losses. Spielerschutz Sigma Prozessfinanzierungs GmbH finances litigation on behalf of people in Austria who used gambling websites operated under Maltese licenses. The claims concern operators that allegedly offered gambling services in Austria without the license required under Austrian law. Austrian courts have ordered repayments in some cases, and the company has sought to have those judgments recognized and enforced in Malta.

That enforcement effort became more difficult after Malta introduced Bill 55 in June 2023, amending its Gaming Act. The provision, commonly referred to as Malta’s Bill 55, addresses certain claims arising from gambling services authorized under Maltese law. It directs Maltese courts to refuse recognition or enforcement of qualifying foreign judgments on public policy grounds. The dispute before the EU court arose after a Maltese court relied on that amendment to reject a request to enforce an Austrian judgment.

Malta’s Bill 55 and the legal advice dispute

Before the enforcement request was rejected, Spielerschutz Sigma had commissioned legal advice about the risks the amendment posed to its business. Its adviser concluded that the provision conflicted with EU law and would therefore be set aside in Maltese enforcement proceedings. After a Maltese court applied the provision, the company brought a damages claim against the adviser in Vienna.

The company sought to recover the fee it had paid for the opinion and losses it attributed to financing litigation between receipt of that advice and learning that its enforcement request had failed. The legal opinion cost €5,000 and was issued on July 5, 2023. The Maltese court rejected the enforcement request on July 19, and Spielerschutz Sigma was notified of that decision on August 1, according to the CJEU judgment. The Austrian commercial court asked the EU judges to interpret EU law because it considered the answer important to deciding whether the adviser had been at fault. That put a question about cross-border judgment enforcement before the CJEU through a separate dispute about the quality of legal advice.

The CJEU said the Austrian court could assess whether the opinion was reasonably defensible under the law and information available when it was given. The question for the national court is whether the adviser exercised the required professional diligence under Austrian law. The EU judges explained that a legal opinion may be defensible if it has support in relevant case law or legal literature, even when a court later takes a different view.

Vienna court retains damages case over Malta’s Bill 55

Under the preliminary ruling procedure, national courts can ask the CJEU for an interpretation of EU law when the answer is necessary to resolve a real dispute. Here, the judges found that the connection between the requested interpretation and the Austrian damages claim was insufficient. Giving an answer would have amounted to offering an advisory opinion on a question that the Vienna court did not need to decide.

That leaves the commercial court to resolve the dispute over the legal opinion. The CJEU’s judgment determines the admissibility of this particular referral. It leaves open whether Malta’s restriction on recognizing or enforcing qualifying foreign judgments can be reconciled with EU law in proceedings where that answer is necessary to decide the case. It leaves open whether Malta’s Bill 55, which restricts the recognition or enforcement of qualifying foreign judgments, is compatible with EU law in proceedings where that question must be resolved.

More to Explore

Back to top button