Regulation & Legal

Senators demand reversal of CFTC geofencing interpretation

Nine Democratic senators have urged the Commodity Futures Trading Commission to withdraw or suspend its interpretation of prediction-market geofencing requirements, escalating congressional opposition to the agency’s position.

In a November 16 letter to Chairman Michael Selig, the senators challenged the CFTC’s November 5 interpretation of impartial-access requirements for designated contract markets. They argued that its application could conflict with restrictions imposed under state and tribal gaming law and by court orders.

The group includes Adam Schiff, Catherine Cortez Masto, Amy Klobuchar, Jacky Rosen, Maria Cantwell, Alex Padilla, Elissa Slotkin, Patty Murray and Gary Peters. Their intervention broadens the earlier criticism of the directive.

The dispute concerns whether exchanges can restrict access to particular event contracts based on a participant’s location. It has direct implications for sports-related prediction markets facing litigation over the relationship between federal derivatives regulation and state or tribal gambling authority.

Court orders and tribal protections

The senators asked the commission to withdraw its interpretation or freeze implementation while litigation continues. They also sought explicit protection for geographic restrictions required by court orders, adopted to comply with the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act or tribal-state compacts, or imposed voluntarily by an exchange.

“The Commission must withdraw the interpretation or freeze all efforts to implement until litigation is resolved. At minimum, the Commission must expressly state that the following do not violate Regulation 38.151(b): geographic restrictions imposed by court order, those adopted to comply with the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act or tribal-state compacts, and those an exchange adopts voluntarily.”

The underlying CFTC position gives exchanges 30 days to remove inconsistent domestic geographic restrictions or explain to its Division of Market Oversight why compliance is not feasible. That explanation route matters where an exchange faces legal constraints, including a court order requiring geofencing. The interpretation therefore should not be reported as automatically nullifying existing injunctions.

The senators also questioned the timing of the interpretation, which they said followed a federal court order requiring Kalshi to impose geofencing around the lands of the Blue Lake Rancheria tribe in California. They raised concerns about possible coordination between the CFTC and platforms involved in litigation, without presenting evidence establishing that such coordination occurred.

Separately, the senators demanded preservation of relevant communications and records from January 1, 2025, onward, and requested written confirmation by November 23. They raised concerns about possible coordination with platforms involved in litigation, but the letter does not establish that such misconduct occurred. Their demands are a congressional intervention, rather than a court ruling or a change in the law.

More to Explore

Back to top button