CFTC contests Louisiana prediction-market shutdown

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission has sued Louisiana after a state court ordered prediction-market businesses to stop offering covered event contracts to people in the state. The federal complaint, filed on November 13, seeks declaratory and injunctive relief against Louisiana and officials responsible for enforcing its gambling laws.
The action followed a November 12 temporary restraining order obtained by Attorney General Liz Murrill. The CFTC’s complaint says Louisiana brought its enforcement case against more than 30 entities, including exchanges, brokers and clearing organizations involved in federally regulated derivatives trading.
Louisiana’s order extends beyond accepting customers’ trades. As reproduced in the federal complaint, it covers listing, clearing, settling, brokering and otherwise facilitating specified event contracts involving people located in Louisiana without the required state authorization. Its scope includes sports, elections and award events.
“Event contracts have traded openly in Louisiana for years, in compliance with the Commodity Exchange Act and CFTC regulations,” CFTC Chairman Michael S. Selig said in the commission’s announcement. The agency said the state obtained its order without giving the affected companies advance notice or an opportunity to respond.
Federal lawsuit disputes Louisiana’s licensing authority
The federal government argues that the contracts at issue are swaps governed by the Commodity Exchange Act. Its complaint contends that applying Louisiana’s gambling restrictions to those transactions interferes with the regulatory framework Congress assigned to the CFTC.
Murrill takes the opposing position: prediction-market operators are offering gambling products without Louisiana licenses. Her enforcement action seeks to apply the state’s gambling requirements to businesses that describe their products as federally regulated financial contracts. That jurisdictional disagreement is the substance of the litigation, rather than a question already resolved by the federal complaint.
The case follows the commission’s recent geographic-access directive, which instructed regulated exchanges to address domestic restrictions inconsistent with its impartial-access requirements. That policy has drawn objections from officials who argue that sports contracts fall within state and tribal gambling authority.
Louisiana became the 12th state sued by the CFTC in its defense of federal derivatives jurisdiction, the agency said. The relief requested in its complaint includes preventing state enforcement against covered federally regulated activity and stopping enforcement or extension of the November 12 order.



